Srpske NovineSrpske Novine

Live-Action Moana Divides Fans: Johnson's Wig and CGI

Disney's live-action remake reaches theaters on July 10, and reactions to the trailers are sharply split, from Johnson's wig to a flood of digital effects.

Ivana Veljković3 min read0
Podeli
Dwayne Johnson, who plays the demigod Maui in the live-action Moana, at a film festival
Dwayne Johnson reprises the demigod Maui in the live-action Moana./ Photo: Wikimedia Commons
In brief
  • Live-action Moana reaches theaters on July 10, directed by Thomas Kail.
  • Dwayne Johnson returns as Maui, while newcomer Catherine Laga'aia takes the title role.
  • Trailer criticism targets Johnson's wig, a so-called muscle suit and an overload of CGI.
  • Rotten Tomatoes projects a critics' score around 60 percent and an opening near $85 million.

There is one shot in the trailers that, quite by accident, has become a test for the whole premiere: Dwayne Johnson stands on the open sea, his hair falling to his shoulders, and audiences online are looking not at the waves behind him but, one by one, at his wig. When the wig becomes the leading character before the film has even reached theaters, an editor knows this is no ordinary summer release but a small study of how far viewers’ patience with Disney’s remake factory now stretches, a machine that has spent years monetizing nostalgia to a fixed recipe.

The live-action adaptation of Moana arrives on the big screen on July 10, directed by Thomas Kail, a man better known to audiences for the stage hip-hop musical Hamilton than for spectacle on the open water. Johnson again plays the demigod Maui, a role he also voiced in the 2016 animated original, while the title heroine is played by newcomer Catherine Laga’aia. That pairing of a proven star and a fresh face was meant to be the campaign’s ace, and instead became the trigger for a split.

What does live-action Moana actually add to the original?

That is the question hanging over the whole project, because the animated Moana was already visually lavish, with an ocean that behaves like a character and colors that an animated film is allowed to indulge without apology. Translate such a world into live-action and you are trapped between two logics. On one side is the promise that everything will look more real, more tangible, closer to the viewer. On the other is the fact that nearly every frame is still built digitally, so the reality you are promising is drawn in a computer after all, only this time with actors dropped into it.

Hence the unease around Maui. Part of the audience sees in Johnson’s appearance a so-called muscle suit and a digitally enhanced physique rather than a body and movement we would accept as natural, so the demigod, richly stylized in the animation, reads in the live-action version as something between a man and a computer sketch. The wig is merely the most visible symptom of a wider problem: when the eye cannot tell where the acting ends and the effect begins, it latches onto a detail and stays there.

Wig, muscles and the arithmetic of the box office

For all that, the split over the trailers need not be bad news for the studio, since even the quarrel over looks turns into free publicity. Rotten Tomatoes for now projects a critics’ score somewhere around 60 percent, that lukewarm middle band in which a film is neither a flop nor a triumph but merchandise sold on the recognizability of its title. A projected opening of about $85 million in North America puts Moana in the same range as last year’s live-action How to Train Your Dragon, another remake that proved audiences still buy a ticket for a story they already know by heart.

And there lies the heart of the dilemma this premiere opens up. Disney learned long ago that nostalgia need not be flawlessly executed to pay off; it only needs to be recognizable. So it is entirely possible for the film to disappoint part of the original’s fanbase and fill cinemas at the same time, because the decision to watch is made here not on the basis of reviews but on the basis of memory. The question is not whether Moana will earn money, but how many more times we are willing to pay for the same story before recognizability stops being enough. Would you go to the cinema for a live-action version of an animated film you already love, or is the original quite enough for you?

Podeli
Komentari…
Next storyLive-Action Moana Opens Soft, Draws Cold ReviewsDisney's live-action Moana has been in theaters since July 10, but it is opening below expectations, facing mostly negative reviews on a budget of about $250 million.

From other sections

Most read today

  1. Greece vs Serbia: Zivkovic and Dragojevic Out in Volos
  2. Stevandic re-elected Republika Srpska parliament speaker
  3. Student List to Elect Assembly Speaker by Majority Vote
  4. Air Serbia Bars Montenegrin Fans From Larnaca Flight
  5. Kos regrets Oj Kosovo song at EU enlargement forum

Komentari (0)

Ostavi komentar

Komentari prolaze kratku moderaciju. Lični napadi i govor mržnje se brišu.

Još nema komentara. Budi prvi i podeli mišljenje.