Study Finds Bacteria and Archaea Evolved Separately
Analysis of 420 metabolic reactions shows the last common ancestor of all cells lacked enzymes for half of them. The authors conclude bacteria and archaea became free-living cells independently.

An international team led by Heinrich Heine University Dusseldorf published a paper on the origin of life on August 5 in the journal Science Advances, arguing that free living cells did not appear once, but twice. The university released its statement on the paper on August 11. The lead author is Natalia Mrnjavac, the senior author is biologist William Martin, and the conclusion concerns a period roughly four billion years ago: the bacterial and archaeal lineages, the authors argue, crossed into free living existence independently of each other.
That runs against the textbook picture, in which all life descends from a single free living ancestor. Biologists split living things into eukaryotes, cells with a nucleus, and older lineages without one, the prokaryotes. Prokaryotes comprise two primordial lineages, bacteria and archaea, and many of them still inhabit hydrothermal vents on the ocean floor today, a setting some theories treat as the cradle of life. The Dusseldorf paper addresses exactly that point, the passage from chemistry to cell.
Half of Metabolism Without Enzymes
The team took a different route than earlier research into early evolution. Instead of individual genes, it worked with an entire set of 420 chemical reactions by which cells turn compounds available on the young Earth, hydrogen, ammonia and carbon dioxide, into the building blocks of life: amino acids, RNA bases and vitamins. That set of reactions is called metabolism and, according to the authors, it is conserved just as universally as the genetic code. Genomes, protein structures and the reactions themselves were analyzed side by side.
The result ran opposite to expectation.
“The surprise is that the enzymes that catalyze these reactions are not conserved across the evolutionary divide that separates bacteria from archaea. We found that the last universal common ancestor of all cells had enzymes for only about half of the metabolic reactions. The other half was catalyzed by metals in the environment where that ancestor arose.”
That is how Martin, the paper’s senior author, described the key finding in the university’s statement. In other words, the common ancestor was not a self-contained cell doing everything on its own, but a system that left half the work to its surroundings. Metals in that role were also described by Harun Tuysuz, an inorganic chemist at the Max Planck Institute for Coal Research and the Spanish materials institute IMDEA: “Metals that occur naturally in hydrothermal vents can replace a surprisingly large number of enzymes in metabolism.”
From this the team reconstructed four phases of early catalysis:
- a phase in which catalysis runs exclusively through metals
- a mixed phase of metals and enzymes, in the last universal common ancestor
- a divergence toward the ancestors of bacteria, with new enzymes emerging
- a divergence toward the ancestors of archaea, also with new enzymes emerging
In those last two phases, new enzymes took over the work from inorganic catalysts in the environment. Because they appeared separately, the authors see this as the basis for the independent emergence of the two lineages into self-sufficient life. “We would see two very different kinds of cells appearing, pioneer bacteria and pioneer archaea, making their first attempts at life outside the boundaries of the hydrothermal vent,” Mrnjavac said, describing what would be visible if it were possible to go back four billion years.
Where Did the Energy Come From Before ATP?
Today’s metabolism draws its energy mainly from adenosine triphosphate, a complex molecule built by enzymes. No such molecule could have existed on the ocean floor before the first cell arose, so the question of what powered early chemistry was left open. The answer the team offers comes from the lab, not from a genome.
“When we let phosphite, a form of phosphorus that occurs naturally in hydrothermal vents, react with organic compounds, we get metabolic phosphorylation reactions overnight in water. Phosphite and palladium stand in for ATP and enzymes, and that is remarkable, it makes early evolution far easier to understand.”
That is what Manon Schlicker of the Dusseldorf team said in the statement. Palladium, a metal chemists have used as a catalyst for a century, is among the metals that occur naturally in hydrothermal vents.
A network of 420 reactions, in which many compounds take part in more than one, is a hard problem mathematically, so part of the work went into a method for ordering the reactions from simplest to most complex. Mike Steel of the University of Canterbury in New Zealand explained where that started: “The first question is whether a unique order for these reactions exists at all. Once we managed to prove that it does, the algorithm for arranging them became solvable.” Alongside the Dusseldorf researchers, the team includes scientists from universities in Germany, Canada, France and New Zealand, plus Max Planck Institutes and Madrid’s IMDEA.
The conclusion Martin draws goes beyond biochemistry:
“The new data leave only one conclusion. The bacterial and archaeal lineages crossed into free living existence independently. Only free living cells are alive. Let’s call it what it is: we are looking at one origin of the genetic code, but two origins of life.”
What This Study Does Not Prove
The finding is a reconstruction, not a record. The conclusion of two origins of life rests on the fact that the enzymes for the same reactions do not match between bacteria and archaea today, an observation about living organisms from which a state four billion years in the past is inferred backward. No fossils of that transition exist.
Nor does the phosphite and palladium experiment show what actually happened, only what is chemically possible in water, without enzymes. The gap between a possible path and the real one remains open here.
The paper itself does not challenge the single origin of the genetic code, the authors explicitly retain it. What is contested is the moment of transition into an independent cell, and that is what other teams should now test against their own data. The paper has been peer reviewed and carries the digital object identifier 10.1126/sciadv.aef3128, but it is a single study, and a shift this large in interpretation needs replication before it belongs in a textbook.



