NASA: Heliosphere Shrank Below Earth's Orbit Three Times
Two new NASA papers show the Sun's protective bubble shrank below Earth's orbit three times in the past 14 million years, and that superflares from the young Sun once warmed early Earth.

NASA published a statement on August 24 tying together two new scientific papers on the Sun’s history and its effects on Earth. A team built around SHIELD (Solar Wind with Hydrogen Ion charge Exchange and Large scale Dynamics), one of NASA’s DRIVE Science Centers, used computer models to reconstruct the path of the heliosphere, the bubble of solar wind that envelops the entire solar system, as it travels through the galaxy. The model shows that over the past several million years the heliosphere shrank at least three times to a diameter smaller than Earth’s orbit, temporarily leaving the planet outside its protective bubble. A second paper, from an independent team at NASA’s Goddard Space Flight Center, tackles a much older period and explains how the young, fainter Sun managed to warm early Earth at all.
Until now, explanations for sharp climate shifts in Earth’s distant past, including periods of abrupt change in average temperature, have mostly looked at factors within the planetary system itself: shifts in orbit, greenhouse gas concentrations, the advance and retreat of ice. The new research adds an external factor, the environment the solar system passes through as it orbits the center of the Milky Way. The heliosphere is created by a continuous stream of charged particles the Sun sends out in every direction, and it acts as a shield against cosmic radiation and interstellar matter.
When the Heliosphere Shrank
The paper is led by Merav Opher, principal investigator of the SHIELD center at Boston University. Her team’s simulations show that over the past several million years the solar system has passed through cold interstellar clouds of gas and dust at least three times. According to the model, this happened roughly two to three million years ago, six to seven million years ago, and 13 to 14 million years ago. On all three occasions, the pressure the clouds put on the heliosphere was strong enough to compress the bubble below Earth’s orbit, leaving the planet exposed to a different galactic environment. The paper was published August 21 in the Annual Review of Astronomy and Astrophysics.
The simulation’s results did not stay purely theoretical. Elements typical of interstellar dust have turned up in deep sea sediment samples, in Antarctic ice, and in samples brought back from the Moon, and they date to exactly the periods the model identifies. That match between the geological record and the computer reconstruction is what sets this paper apart from earlier attempts to explain climate swings without geological data behind them.
What Is the Faint Young Sun Paradox?
The second paper solves an older problem. The Sun is 4.6 billion years old, and three billion years ago it shone at only about 70 percent of its current strength. By simple arithmetic, Earth under such a faint Sun should have been a fully frozen ball, yet geological evidence shows liquid water already existed at the time. Science calls that gap the faint young Sun paradox.
The paper, led by Vladimir Airapetian of NASA’s Goddard Space Flight Center in Greenbelt, Maryland, and published in The Astrophysical Journal Letters, proposes that the answer lies in superflares, the massive particle eruptions that young Sun-like stars still produce today. In laboratory simulations, the team bombarded a gas mixture that mimics early Earth’s atmosphere with protons and produced nitrous oxide, a greenhouse gas 300 times more potent than carbon dioxide. Even if only 10 percent of that gas survived, since the young Sun’s ultraviolet radiation breaks part of it back down, early Earth’s equatorial belt would have been about five degrees Celsius warmer, enough to keep temperatures above water’s freezing point.
The two papers describe two entirely different mechanisms on different timescales. Passages through cold interstellar clouds, measured in millions of years, do not explain the warming problem of a Sun that was young billions of years ago, and vice versa, so the two should not be folded into a single explanation of Earth’s climate history. Both conclusions rest on computer models and laboratory simulations rather than direct measurements of the atmosphere from those periods, so the geological samples the researchers cite confirm agreement with the model, not the underlying mechanism itself.



