Srpske NovineSrpske Novine

Yonsei Fires Back at Nobel Laureates on Universe's Expansion

A Southampton team with Nobel laureates Adam Riess and Brian Schmidt defends the universe's accelerating expansion; Yonsei answered on August 26 that the analysis has two flaws.

Aleksandar Tomić4 min read0
Podeli
Artistic illustration of the expansion of the universe over time
The dispute over dark energy and the accelerating expansion of the universe continues between two teams of cosmologists./ Photo: Phys.org

A team of scientists gathered around the University of Southampton, including 2011 Nobel Prize in Physics winners Adam Riess and Brian Schmidt, has published an analysis in the Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society defending the position that the universe’s expansion is still accelerating. The analysis answers a paper from Yonsei University in South Korea, published in November 2025, which argued the opposite: that once age bias in the measurements is corrected, the expansion is actually slowing down. Now Yonsei University has published, on August 26, a new paper responding to the Southampton analysis, stating that it has two methodological problems. The dispute concerns dark energy, a force nobody actually understands, which makes up roughly 70 percent of the universe.

Srpske.rs already covered Yonsei University’s original claim, that the universe might have entered a phase of deceleration rather than acceleration, in the article “Yonsei University: the universe may not be accelerating after all.” That claim rested on the idea that type Ia supernovae, the main measuring tool that revealed cosmic acceleration in the first place, do not reach the same peak brightness as the universe ages. If that is true, astronomers could have been misreading the data for decades, interpreting acceleration where none actually exists.

What the Southampton Team Argues

The Southampton analysis is led by Phil Wiseman of the University of Southampton and was first presented in June 2026, before being formally published in the Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, volume 549, issue 3, under the designation 10.1093/mnras/stag797. According to a statement from the Royal Astronomical Society, the team found that the Yonsei paper had equated the age of the host galaxy with the age of the star that later exploded as a supernova, instead of treating them separately. The team also states that the earlier analysis did not properly account for the mass of the host galaxies, a step it describes as standard in modern cosmology.

“The previous, well-established measurements were, in fact, fine, and our current understanding of the fate of the universe remains solid,” Wiseman said in the Royal Astronomical Society’s statement.

Wiseman added that “thankfully, we’ve averted this crisis, but the mystery of why the universe’s expansion rate is still accelerating remains.” Adam Riess, a co-author of the paper, was more direct in the same statement.

“Extraordinary claims require particularly careful scrutiny. What we find is that when we calibrate these supernovae accounting for different environments and populations of host galaxies, the evidence for cosmic acceleration remains extremely consistent,” Riess said.

Mark Sullivan, a professor at the University of Southampton and co-author of the paper, also left the door open: “While this idea didn’t turn out to be correct, it opened up new ways of thinking about how supernovae explode,” Sullivan said in the same statement.

Yonsei Disagrees

Yonsei University does not accept that conclusion. The team, led by professor Young-Wook Lee, with Chul Chung as first author, published a response in the same journal on August 26, under the designation 10.1093/mnras/stag1513. The dispute centers on what is known as the age bias slope, the relationship between the brightness of a type Ia supernova and the age of the star it came from.

The Yonsei team raises two problems. The first is that the Southampton analysis combined supernovae from wide redshift ranges, which, according to Yonsei, artificially flattens the measured age bias slope. The second concerns the model for light extinction by cosmic dust and its dependence on host galaxy mass, which Yonsei says runs counter to what large samples of observed galaxies actually show.

“The shallow age bias slope reported in the rebuttal is thus a result of a clear methodological problem in the analysis,” Chung said alongside the paper published on August 26.

Lee said the burden of proof lies with the side defending acceleration.

“To defend an extraordinary claim like the accelerating expansion of the universe, one must first show that this underlying assumption is correct,” Lee said.

“Under these circumstances, we must seriously reconsider whether the evidence still supports an accelerating universe,” Lee added in the same statement.

What This Exchange Does Not Prove

Neither the Southampton nor the Yonsei analysis, for all that, delivers a final answer. Both sides rely on the same kinds of type Ia supernova data, interpreted differently, and no new independent measurement has since settled the dispute in either side’s favor. The Yonsei team is announcing what it calls an age-evolution-free test, which would use only supernovae from young galaxies of similar age across the full redshift range; preliminary results of that test, Yonsei says, are consistent with its earlier finding. Larger samples expected from the Vera Rubin Observatory should allow for a more precise check.

Until then, the claim that the universe is expanding at an accelerating rate remains the measurement best supported by the available data, but not a question closed to further scrutiny. The debate itself shows how sensitive the interpretation of the age and composition of host galaxies is to the final cosmological conclusion, and that the question of what dark energy actually is remains open regardless of which side’s analysis eventually proves correct.

Podeli
Komentari…
Next storyHidden Force in Dark Matter Slows Cosmic Structure GrowthA calculation published in JCAP shows an extra attractive force between dark matter particles slows cosmic structure growth, since the particles effectively lose mass as the universe expands.

From other sections

Most read today

  1. Greece vs Serbia: Zivkovic and Dragojevic Out in Volos
  2. Student List to Elect Assembly Speaker by Majority Vote
  3. Air Serbia Bars Montenegrin Fans From Larnaca Flight
  4. Guard says it targeted US radar in Bahrain
  5. GENGE map shows 125,054 active Serbian business entities

Komentari (0)

Ostavi komentar

Komentari prolaze kratku moderaciju. Lični napadi i govor mržnje se brišu.

Još nema komentara. Budi prvi i podeli mišljenje.